Most people think audio description is “just reading the script.”
Yeah, no.
That’s why some audio description for video sounds like a book report slapped onto a TV show. It’s … serviceable. But does it feel like part of the story? Not usually.
And then someone like Dave Wallace comes along.
A reviewer, John Stark (Mac The Movie Guy), said this about his track on The Paper Man:
“What Dave is doing doesn’t even feel like audio description, although it is. He’s providing the same function, but it feels like he’s cast in the series.”
That’s the difference. Same script. Same words. But one sounds like a patch job. The other sounds like it was built into the show from the start.
That’s integrated audio description. That’s performance.
⸻
Same Words, Different World
Ten narrators can read the same line. Only the ones who know what they’re doing will make you forget you’re listening to description at all. That’s the gap between “reader” and “performer.”
TTS (text to speech) can spit words. Humans bring rhythm, color, and presence. That’s why audio description best practices need to go beyond clarity and timing. It’s not just “how to read audio description.” It’s how to perform it.
The Pushback Is Real
Not everyone wants performative audio description techniques. Some reasons:
Neutrality. In the UK and Europe, AD tends to be restrained and objective. Drop Dave’s playful style there and some audiences would bristle.
Standards. WCAG and ISO stress objectivity. Over-performance risks being seen as “interpretation.”
Genre fit. A mockumentary? Sure. A true-crime doc? Not so much.
Audience split. Even that review admitted: “This will absolutely not work for some people.”
So yeah, the pushback is valid. But ignoring it won’t make it go away.
Why That Review Hit So Hard
Part of why people loved Dave’s track is novelty. It stood out from the usual audio description examples. Another part? The show itself-a faux-documentary-was a perfect sandbox for integrated audio description.
So was it brilliant performance? Yes. Was it also context, bias, and timing? Also yes.
So What Is Performance in AD?
Let’s clear this up: performance doesn’t mean acting out characters. No goofy accents. No melodrama.
Performance means integration. It means:
Breathing with the rhythm of the edit.
Dropping your voice into gaps like you belong there.
Matching tone without stealing spotlight.
It’s the illusion of invisibility. And that “invisible” effect takes conscious, trained audio description techniques.
⸻
Standards vs. Craft
Yes, there are standards. And you should know them. But standards don’t tell you how to sound like you belong in the world of a comedy vs. a thriller vs. a documentary.
That’s craft. That’s what audio description tips are really about.
Think of it like this: the script is the map. The performance is the journey. You need both, but only one makes it worth the trip.
The Real Future of AD
Streaming companies want scale, so TTS is tempting. But reviews like the one Dave got prove something else: audiences notice when audio description for video is more than text delivery.
That’s not going away. In fact, as more people hear the difference, the demand for narrators who can deliver integrated audio description will only grow.
If You’re an Audio Description Performer for Entertainment, Listen Up
Reading well isn’t the ceiling. It’s the floor.
If you want to move from “reader” to “performer,” here’s where to start:
Don’t bulldoze into silence. Slip in.
Match the show’s rhythm (not your own).
Find tone with that high wire act of emotional nuance. You’re not stealing the scene; you’re holding it steady.
That’s what makes people forget they’re listening to description and just watch the show. That’s the heart of modern audio description best practices.
Why I’m Hammering This for Ten Plus Years
Because this isn’t about one flashy review. It’s about the long game of what is audio description becoming. Standards matter. But so does audience experience. And right now, the sticky, memorable stuff is that emotional nuance, the high wire act, coming from those voice over professionals who treat AD as performance.
So AD Performers: you’ve got a choice. Keep” reading words”. Or start performing them.
Call to Action
If you’re ready to make that leap-from “functional reader” to “integrated performer” that’s what I coach.
📘 Grab my book at roysamuelson.com/book
Check out the A.D. Playback Lounge – Build your instincts behind the mic at a safe, supportive space to take your studies and practice Audio Description performance.
🎙 Catch the next workshop at RoySamuelson.com
🎧 Dive into theADNA podcast
And if you’re serious about leveling up your narration, subscribe on the bottom of any RoySamuelson.com page, because my membership for AD performers is coming. That’s where we’ll drill into performance craft that TTS can’t touch.
Dave Wallace’s website https://davewallacevo.com
Mac The movie Guy Review https://macthemovieguy.com/2025/09/08/the-small-screen-diaries-09-07-25/